Globo Madrid - Gary Neville Criticizes Pochettino’s De Ligt Selection After Liverpool Defeat

Madrid -

IN THE NEWS

Gary Neville Criticizes Pochettino’s De Ligt Selection After Liverpool Defeat
Gary Neville Criticizes Pochettino’s De Ligt Selection After Liverpool Defeat

Gary Neville Criticizes Pochettino’s De Ligt Selection After Liverpool Defeat

Gary Neville has publicly questioned Mauricio Pochettino’s tactical choices following Manchester United’s defeat to Liverpool, specifically targeting the selection of Matthijs de Ligt. The former United defender argued that De Ligt was ill-prepared for the intensity of the Premier League after a long absence from competitive play.

Text size:

Gary Neville has voiced strong criticism regarding Mauricio Pochettino’s team selection for Manchester United’s match against Liverpool, specifically questioning the decision to recall Matthijs de Ligt to the starting lineup. The former United defender argued that De Ligt was ill-equipped for the demands of top-flight football after a significant period away from competitive action.

The controversy surrounding the Dutch international’s fitness emerged early in the contest at Anfield. In the tenth minute, Liverpool launched an attack that exposed vulnerabilities in United’s defensive structure. Ronald Araujo delivered a hopeful ball over the top, which De Ligt failed to deal with effectively, allowing Alexander Isak to race into space behind the defense.

The situation deteriorated further moments later when Leny Yoro clattered into Isak from behind on the edge of the penalty area. Referee Samuel Barrott issued a straight red card to Yoro, reducing United to ten men and compounding their early troubles. Dominik Szoboszlai converted the resulting free-kick to open the scoring, before Florian Wirtz added a second inside thirteen minutes.

Speaking for Sky Sports during the broadcast, Neville described his reaction upon seeing De Ligt’s name on the teamsheet as one of absolute astonishment. He pointed to the defender’s recent history as evidence that he was not yet ready for such a high-stakes fixture.

"When I saw Matthijs de Ligt’s name on the teamsheet, I have to be honest with you, I was absolutely stunned," Neville said. "The reason I was stunned was because of this: if you watched him against Como four weeks ago, he was very much well of it. That is just a basic ball over the top of him. It’s his problem to start with."

Neville suggested that De Ligt had been exposed by the lack of recent match intensity. He noted that the Netherlands international had been out for approximately a year and was struggling to regain the necessary level of sharpness required for Premier League defenses.

"We saw it against Como and he’s been out for a year, trying to come back to this level of football. It’s really tough," Neville continued. "To have De Ligt out there in a game like this, in a back four, he’s been exposed inside the first ten minutes."

While De Ligt bore the brunt of Neville’s tactical critique, the former England international also highlighted significant errors from his fellow center-back, Leny Yoro. Neville argued that Yoro’s positioning was fundamentally flawed and that his failure to cover for De Ligt contributed directly to the defensive collapse.

"Yoro can be further across but if you look at De Ligt in this channel, he’s miles away from him," Neville explained. "Yoro should be across, yes, he can get further around. He has to cover and he doesn’t. He reacts late, his anticipation is really poor."

Neville characterized Yoro’s decision-making as naive, particularly given the young defender’s age and experience level. He acknowledged that while Isak had delayed his run slightly to ensure contact, Yoro’s failure to play the ball and his clumsy challenge left him with no option but a red card.

"He’s not happy with it, Mauricio Pochettino," Neville noted regarding the referee’s decision. "You could argue with it, Isak just delays slightly to make sure that Yoro runs into the back of him. But unfortunately, when you’re a young defender, you’re going to get caught like that and it’s naivety."

The defensive performance drew parallels to United’s previous struggles under interim management. Neville remarked that former United midfielder Michael Carrick, who had overseen the team in recent weeks, would likely recognize the recurring issues.

"Michael Carrick will be watching this at home and thinking, 'Yeah, that’s what I was having to deal with two weeks ago', it’s so poor," Neville said. "Yoro has got to be across and around the other centre-back. You’ve got to cover your mate and he doesn’t. It’s really just bad all round from Manchester United."

Neville’s colleague Jamie Carragher echoed these sentiments on commentary, describing United’s defensive start as "absolutely shocking." Carragher emphasized that the error leading to the first goal was not a sophisticated pass but a simple clearance by Araujo that United failed to handle.

"It’s as bad as it gets from two centre-backs," Carragher said. "The ball from Ronald Araujo… it wasn’t even a pass, it’s just a clearance, a hopeful ball through the middle."

The defeat marked a difficult start to Pochettino’s tenure as United manager, with the coaching staff facing immediate scrutiny over player fitness and tactical cohesion in one of the most demanding fixtures in English football.

R.Romero--GM